Infinite sum = product puzzle Michael Somos somos@cis.csuohio.edu 12 May 2004 (21 Sep 2007 tweak) Suppose you have two rational functions f(x)=x*(1-x)^2*(1-x^2)/(1-x^6) and g(x)=(1-x)*(1-x^6)^6/(1-x^2)^2/(1-x^3)^3 . Then f(x)+f(x^2)+f(x^3)+... = x*g(x)*g(x^2)*g(x^3)*... . The puzzle is to find all such function pairs. The rules are that f(x) is a product with one factor x and the rest are all of the form (1-x^k) or 1/(1-x^k), and similarly for g(x) but it has no factors of x. I know of just eleven solutions of this puzzle including the one listed above. Probably there are no others. It would be nice to generalize this in an interesting way by weakening the rules to allow more solutions. For example, one could allow f(x) to have a polynomial factor not of the form (1-x^k). Another possibilty is to require that the power series expansion coefficients of f(x) to be a periodic sequence. These are just two examples that I thought of.